Hm, for some reason this post never got published. Made a lot more sense the week I saw three nuclear weapons disarmed on TV, but here it is:
Disarming a nuclear weapon pops up occasionally on TV and in movies (I'm looking at you Chuck, Castle and even SGU). They always make it seem like a super complicated task. I'm not sure that it is all that difficult (this is one of those posts where I'm way outside my realm of knowledge).
What I'm willing to concede:
-Even if you know how to disarm a nuclear bomb it would be crazy scary.
-Conventional bombs may have fake wires and components that will cause the bomb to explode if tampered with and it is possible that a nuclear bomb would also have this.
But:
Nuclear weapons are really hard to make. Getting the material may be the hardest part, but even with the material it is quite a task. My understanding is those scientists at Los Alamos (many of the greatest in American history) were provided the radio active material. Today a semi-trained bomb maker with some parts from radio shack and a lawn store can make a conventional bomb, but only certain governments have made nuclear weapons.
Something that hard to make shouldn't be too hard to stop.
Typically nuclear weapons work by using a conventional explosive to smash two pieces of radio active material together. Dirty bombs work by having a conventional bomb spread radio active material. So the key is just to separate the radioactive part from the conventional weapon.
Yes it is good to stop the conventional weapon as well to avoid any damage and yes the bomb maker might make that tricky, but then the scary part is disarming a bomb, not disarming a NUCLEAR bomb.
Ok, maybe it isn't super easy, but definitely seems more straight forward than whatever they end up doing on TV. Plus while they are screwing around with guessing which wire they could be trying to get the material and conventional bomb as far away from each other as possible.
I took a look on the web to see what others think and here's wired's take.
Tuesday, June 21, 2011
Tuesday, June 14, 2011
Patent Granted!
For those who missed it on the twitter feed, I'm first inventor on a patent that was just granted!
For those who did see it on the twitter feed this link includes the pretty pictures along with the text:
MULTIPLE BATTERY CONFIGURATIONS IN AN IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICE.
Actually the link above is the application, here's the link to the granted patent.
For those who did see it on the twitter feed this link includes the pretty pictures along with the text:
MULTIPLE BATTERY CONFIGURATIONS IN AN IMPLANTABLE MEDICAL DEVICE.
Actually the link above is the application, here's the link to the granted patent.
Sunday, June 05, 2011
The Magicians
I read The Magicians during a pause between installments of the wheel of time. It is a twist on Harry Potter/Narnia. It presents these stories based on what would "really" happen if someone was transported off to a magical land where they learn that they can cast spells.
This book's take is that learning to do magic would be very difficult and tedious, much like studying any other difficult subject and would eventually become a standard task rather than an exciting adventure.
The other big difference starts with the observation that typically the main characters in these stories aren't happy in the real world then find happiness in the magical world. This book claims that if the characters aren't happy people they aren't going to be happy no matter what world they end up in. Part of this is the book shows how relationships with others as well as various mundane aspects of life do much more to influence a person's happiness than the world that surrounds the person.
On one hand it is somewhat humorous and a change of pace to see this take on the genre. However, a book that shows a character being unhappy in a series of settings really isn't much fun. Also as part of the "real" take there isn't a clear goal or direction at any point in the book so I often found myself asking if the story is going anywhere or if I'm just meandering around in this world. There is a somewhat interesting plot line running through the book, but it isn't really revealed till near the end. I also thought that the book made the main points through the story, then made them a bit more obvious, then stated them outright in dialogue. I think it would have had more impact if it stopped when the message was a little more subtle.
I'm tempted to recommend this book to anyone who reads a lot of fantasy as something different to throw into the mix. However, if someone reads a lot of fantasy it is probably because they enjoy those magical worlds and don't want to read a book where those worlds aren't that great.
This book's take is that learning to do magic would be very difficult and tedious, much like studying any other difficult subject and would eventually become a standard task rather than an exciting adventure.
The other big difference starts with the observation that typically the main characters in these stories aren't happy in the real world then find happiness in the magical world. This book claims that if the characters aren't happy people they aren't going to be happy no matter what world they end up in. Part of this is the book shows how relationships with others as well as various mundane aspects of life do much more to influence a person's happiness than the world that surrounds the person.
On one hand it is somewhat humorous and a change of pace to see this take on the genre. However, a book that shows a character being unhappy in a series of settings really isn't much fun. Also as part of the "real" take there isn't a clear goal or direction at any point in the book so I often found myself asking if the story is going anywhere or if I'm just meandering around in this world. There is a somewhat interesting plot line running through the book, but it isn't really revealed till near the end. I also thought that the book made the main points through the story, then made them a bit more obvious, then stated them outright in dialogue. I think it would have had more impact if it stopped when the message was a little more subtle.
I'm tempted to recommend this book to anyone who reads a lot of fantasy as something different to throw into the mix. However, if someone reads a lot of fantasy it is probably because they enjoy those magical worlds and don't want to read a book where those worlds aren't that great.
Wednesday, May 18, 2011
Banker To The Poor
I read Banker To The Poor over the last few days. Thanks Mom for lending it to me.
The book is interesting and I think contains some good lessons. However, there are several aspects of it that I take issue with.
First the good stuff:
-It is very impressive to see how the author started from nothing and built this huge organization that does a ton of good.
-I like the focus on serving the absolute poorest people in society. So often there is a focus on helping the middle class. Helping the middle class is nice, but the society's focus should really be on the poor.
-He has a focus on how money tends to get pulled toward the already well off. So it is important to make sure that money intended to help the poor should go directly to the poor.
-There is a decent amount of information about how microfinance works (although this is not a microfinace how to).
-There is some discussion of social entrepreneurship which seems to be picking up significant popularity. And at the end he provides an outline of how socially focused business should be run. Although I do think his suggestion may be a little too utopian.
-In general I liked any portion where he talked about how he built Grameen Bank, but had issues when he made broad comments about the role of government and put down other ways of helping the poor.
Parts I have some issue with (here's me telling a Nobel Prize winner what he got wrong in his book about his career):
-He is very down on the role of government in helping the poor. I can see where he is coming from, but at the same time it was government money and involvement that helped Grameen Bank take off. Sure now that it is able to finance itself it no longer needs government help, but that doesn't mean the government has no role to play in helping the poor or other organizations trying to help the poor.
-Often times he states how little money the loans were that turned people's lives around. But when he converts these numbers to dollars he doesn't relate them to the difference in cost of living. If he was trying to get people from the US to donate money then that's fine to say just $500 will pull this person in Bangladesh out of poverty. But he's not looking for donations, he is talking about a self sustaining bank so I feel like the numbers should be adjust to give a sense of how they big they are to the locals of the country under discussion. There is a portion where he talks about microfinace in the US, but most of the examples are set in Bangladesh.
-He repeatedly makes the case that the poor don't need training, just support (such as credit). He believes that given the opportunity they are entrepreneurs and can figure out how to make money. Clearly this has worked on a large scale for him. But I have to imagine that training has its place. The examples of businesses started for the most part don't sound like something that can expand very much. So it helps pull that person out of poverty, but it probably doesn't provide jobs for the neighbors. But I think that business started by people with more training would have more growth potential. In addition he even has stories of ventures that Grameen Bank started that required getting its staff trained and then training the local workers (such as running the fisheries). So I'll believe that training isn't as important as most people think, but I think he goes too far in putting it down.
-I appreciate that this is his story that he is telling. And he is good at giving credit to people who supported him along the way. But I would have appreciated more context of what else was going on in the world of microfinance over this period (which stretches from the mid 70s to mid 2000s). Did he really come up with the idea and implement it and all other microfinace programs are just based on his work? Or more likely, was there other work in the field and other efforts going on around the same time?
-He talks a little bit about the obstacles along the way, but he focuses heavily on the success. I think it would have been more informative to hear more about the issues he had and how they were over come. In many ways this book felt like a sales pitch.
-Well, it felt like he was giving a sales pitch without having anything to sell. A lot of what I got out of this book is most of what I'd normally try to do to help the poor is no good. And I really didn't see many suggestions on what I should do if I do want to help. Ok, he does suggest starting a company with minimal profit motive, but short of that I sorta feel like he's saying don't bother trying to help. Which doesn't seem right. There must be some middle step.
That's a lot I took issue with but overall I really did like the book and do think the author put some incredible ideas to use to do a huge amount of good.
The book is interesting and I think contains some good lessons. However, there are several aspects of it that I take issue with.
First the good stuff:
-It is very impressive to see how the author started from nothing and built this huge organization that does a ton of good.
-I like the focus on serving the absolute poorest people in society. So often there is a focus on helping the middle class. Helping the middle class is nice, but the society's focus should really be on the poor.
-He has a focus on how money tends to get pulled toward the already well off. So it is important to make sure that money intended to help the poor should go directly to the poor.
-There is a decent amount of information about how microfinance works (although this is not a microfinace how to).
-There is some discussion of social entrepreneurship which seems to be picking up significant popularity. And at the end he provides an outline of how socially focused business should be run. Although I do think his suggestion may be a little too utopian.
-In general I liked any portion where he talked about how he built Grameen Bank, but had issues when he made broad comments about the role of government and put down other ways of helping the poor.
Parts I have some issue with (here's me telling a Nobel Prize winner what he got wrong in his book about his career):
-He is very down on the role of government in helping the poor. I can see where he is coming from, but at the same time it was government money and involvement that helped Grameen Bank take off. Sure now that it is able to finance itself it no longer needs government help, but that doesn't mean the government has no role to play in helping the poor or other organizations trying to help the poor.
-Often times he states how little money the loans were that turned people's lives around. But when he converts these numbers to dollars he doesn't relate them to the difference in cost of living. If he was trying to get people from the US to donate money then that's fine to say just $500 will pull this person in Bangladesh out of poverty. But he's not looking for donations, he is talking about a self sustaining bank so I feel like the numbers should be adjust to give a sense of how they big they are to the locals of the country under discussion. There is a portion where he talks about microfinace in the US, but most of the examples are set in Bangladesh.
-He repeatedly makes the case that the poor don't need training, just support (such as credit). He believes that given the opportunity they are entrepreneurs and can figure out how to make money. Clearly this has worked on a large scale for him. But I have to imagine that training has its place. The examples of businesses started for the most part don't sound like something that can expand very much. So it helps pull that person out of poverty, but it probably doesn't provide jobs for the neighbors. But I think that business started by people with more training would have more growth potential. In addition he even has stories of ventures that Grameen Bank started that required getting its staff trained and then training the local workers (such as running the fisheries). So I'll believe that training isn't as important as most people think, but I think he goes too far in putting it down.
-I appreciate that this is his story that he is telling. And he is good at giving credit to people who supported him along the way. But I would have appreciated more context of what else was going on in the world of microfinance over this period (which stretches from the mid 70s to mid 2000s). Did he really come up with the idea and implement it and all other microfinace programs are just based on his work? Or more likely, was there other work in the field and other efforts going on around the same time?
-He talks a little bit about the obstacles along the way, but he focuses heavily on the success. I think it would have been more informative to hear more about the issues he had and how they were over come. In many ways this book felt like a sales pitch.
-Well, it felt like he was giving a sales pitch without having anything to sell. A lot of what I got out of this book is most of what I'd normally try to do to help the poor is no good. And I really didn't see many suggestions on what I should do if I do want to help. Ok, he does suggest starting a company with minimal profit motive, but short of that I sorta feel like he's saying don't bother trying to help. Which doesn't seem right. There must be some middle step.
That's a lot I took issue with but overall I really did like the book and do think the author put some incredible ideas to use to do a huge amount of good.
Thursday, April 07, 2011
All I needed was stick figures!
Remember my Shoulder Tapping post from November? No? Ok, fine, well that's what the link is for.
Apparently all that post needed was some stick figures and I'd have written an xkcd comic! (Remember to place the mouse over the comic for a second to get the final message).
Alright, alright, I see how he expressed what took me several paragraphs of text in a series of simple images and how he added extra humor. But still, I think it is kinda awesome. Now I feel like I should go off on more crazy rants on the off chance that Randal will one day go off on a similar rant.
Oh, shit, the irony of being excited after the fact of seeing similarity between one of my 484 blog pots and one of Randal's 882 xkcd posts is just now hitting me. At least it wasn't this post.
And now I'm kind of disturbed that I sometimes think about situations based on blog posts I wrote three years ago. I'm going to try to get back to that excitement I had at the start of this post or maybe just try to get some sleep.
Apparently all that post needed was some stick figures and I'd have written an xkcd comic! (Remember to place the mouse over the comic for a second to get the final message).
Alright, alright, I see how he expressed what took me several paragraphs of text in a series of simple images and how he added extra humor. But still, I think it is kinda awesome. Now I feel like I should go off on more crazy rants on the off chance that Randal will one day go off on a similar rant.
Oh, shit, the irony of being excited after the fact of seeing similarity between one of my 484 blog pots and one of Randal's 882 xkcd posts is just now hitting me. At least it wasn't this post.
And now I'm kind of disturbed that I sometimes think about situations based on blog posts I wrote three years ago. I'm going to try to get back to that excitement I had at the start of this post or maybe just try to get some sleep.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)